Jump to content
Sturgeon's House

Search the Community

Showing results for tags 'please'.



More search options

  • Search By Tags

    Type tags separated by commas.
  • Search By Author

Content Type


Forums

  • The Outer Rim
    • Open Discussion
    • Aerospace
    • Naval Discussion
    • Mechanized Warfare
    • Ballistics Science Discussion
    • Infantry Tools & Tactics
    • Dr. Strangelove's Nuclear Palace
    • Biosciences
    • History, Culture, and Archaeology
    • Fiction & Entertainment
    • Computers, Software, and Tech Support
    • Historical Warfare
    • Sturgeon's Contests

Blogs

  • Of IS-7s and Other Things
  • Archive Awareness
  • Unstart's Blog
  • The Sherman Blog
  • U-47

Calendars

  • Community Calendar

Found 1 result

  1. DRDO; India's Porsche

    I know we already have a topic on the Arjun, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't have another thread about how DRDO can't make anything. I mean, the Arjun program started in 1974 (according to Wikipedia) and the thing got produced 30 years later, in 2004. Should we take a look at the list of tanks that got developed at around the same time period? T-72 T-80 Type 88 Type 96 Type 74 OF-40 Merkava 1 Merkava 2 Merkava 3 Leopard 2 M1 Abrams Challenger 1 M-84 K-1 Type 90 Leclerc T-90 PT-91 Zulfiqar C1 Ariete Challenger 2 TR-85 T-84 ...and many more A keen I will have noticed that these are both second and third generation tanks, which is right, because the development of the Arjun took place during two generations of tanks. Of note is that the Israelis managed to make three Merkava variants in the time DRDO took to develop the Arjun. And if that wasn't enough, he Challenger 1 was developed, build, accepted for service, and taken out of service by the Brits in less time than it took DRDO to deliver the first batch of Arjuns. What the fuck. Alright alright I'll stop the bashing! So lets take a look at the armour of the Arjun: Okay now that we've taken a look at the armour of the Arjun, we can take a look at something of which the Indians pretend is armour. First, the turret 'armour': The first good thing to note about the turret armour is that the left front is decent. The second good thing about the turret armour is that it's so bad I can spend a whole post on burning it down. The mantlet looks thick in this model, but it looks like it's not modeled right since it seems to be fused with the frontal armour itself. This is what the actual armour in the gun mantlet looks like: It's fairly thin, like in the Leclerc, but even worse is that it does not cover the whole gap in the turret. Seriously DRDO, what the fuck? Of course there are pictures of a fully assembled model, but it seems that the completed mantlet is no more than a sheet metal box around the structure shown in the above photo. I mean, look at this: You can see the weld lines and shit on top of the 'mantlet', there is no reason to believe this is a solid steel block. These pictures bring me nicely to the next two points: 1. The turret side basically lacks any and all side armour 2. The gunner sight barely has any armour The green blocks on the turret side in the first picture are actually storage boxes, not armour. The majority of the side is only a few cm thick steel plate. Lets just compare this to the Leopard 2A4 for a second: (Thanks to @Militarysta for making this picture) You can see that the turret side protection extends way, way further back on the Leopard 2A4 than it does on the Arjun. The Arjun only has to rotate the turret slightly to be completely vulnerable to even low caliber autocannons. And as you can imagine, that's not good. You can also see that the armour block behind the gunner sight is around 660 mm LOS, the same spot in the Arjun is estimated to be around 300 mm thick. Don't worry about the lower part of the gun sight, that has no armour at all. The sight itself looks like this: So the turret has negligible side protection, horrible frontal protection, and a shit mantlet. But wait, there's more! The turret roof is really thin. If you take a look at this picture you'd say that it has a decently thick roof: See? That looks to be like a solid few cm thick. So why say the roof is really thin? Well, take a look at this as well: That hatch/cupola is raised. So what looks to be a roof that's a few cm thick is just a raised cupola. Which means that the turret roof itself is horribly thin. And since the front third is sloped forward that means APFSDS can easily yaw into the crew compartment, and lets not speak about attacks from above because that'll end in tears for the Arjun. Is there anything not shit about the Arjun turret? ... No! Actually! A sharp-eyed reader will already have noticed that the turret ammorack has absolutely no protection at all: The inside of the turret itself is a horrible fucking mess, just look at it: That's right, those cables are hanging from fucking string. Since the gun is also in the turret, surely that must be a good part of the turret, right? Right!? I mean, they had until 2004 to select or make a good gun! Aahahahahahahha, no. It's a rifled 120 mm. In 2004. Helloooooo India, welcome to Britain, 19-fucking-80s. ...well maybe they have very good ammunition! No. That's about the same as DM23. Which was introduced in 1983. 1984 saw a medium-high L/D (20+ L/D) penetrator for the US, 1987 for Germany and 1986 for the Soviet Union. We got high L/D (30+ L/D) penetrators in the early 90s. India's still rocking that good-ol' 17 L/D trash. Sooooo will the hull be any better? No. Access hatch in the upper glacis. On TS I was talking to @Collimatrix about how the driver's position most likely makes the upper glacis in front of him thinner, but that turned out not to be true, since... ...his position doesn't reach the fucking glacis in the first place. Not only that, look at how fucking horsewank thin that glacis is. With how thin it is, it's most likely just solid steel instead of NERA, even though the Indians claim it uses NERA, and they have this to say about their NERA: Literally fucking what I could probably go on and on and on about the retardation that's called Arjun, but I won't. I have subjected myself to too much stupidity already since I had to go to fucking places like defenceforumindia which was completely fucking malarious. And if you don't know what that word means, it's a combination of malaria and hilarious since reading defenceforumindia is equal parts sickening and hilarious.
×