Jump to content
Sturgeon's House
Sign in to follow this  
LostCosmonaut

How Does This Board Feel About Robert Zubrin?

Recommended Posts

For those of you who are not familiar with him, Robert Zubrin is an American aerospace engineer and author of some note. He is probably best known for his advocacy of the 'Mars Direct' proposal, although he's also done quite a bit of work in the nuclear spacecraft propulsion field (he's the guy that came up with the NSWR). His wiki page says he's also written on other vaguely political topics, but I'm not familiar with them.

 

 

Personally, I find his work on spacecraft propulsion highly interesting, and it's good that we've got somebody putting forth cogent ideas for space exploration. However, I feel that some of his ideas are a bit too optimistic, especially in regards to his Mars Direct approach. I feel that it would be more optimal to gain more experience with long term off-planet living in a location such as the moon before proceeding to Mars, while also using that time to mature techniques such as nuclear rockets to actually get to Mars. On a related note, I showed his NSWR paper to a guy I know who has some not insignificant knowledge of nuclear physics, and he was a bit skeptical. Still, in my opinion, it's infinitely better to have somebody be a bit overoptimistic about how well their ideas will work, and keeps push them forward, then a bunch of limp wristed pessimists who are afraid to send anyone beyond LEO because it might cost a few million dollars.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My friends who are more inclined to delve into details of rocketry generally consider Zubrin to be insane, but I must admit greatly liking the idea of a propulsion system whose principle revolves around containing a nuclear explosion within a shielded vessel and spurting the resulting energized propellant out of the rocket's ass.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By LostCosmonaut
      Similar to the aviation subforum, a thread to post documents in. Reply with your own contributions.
       
      Launch Vehicles
       
      Advanced Cryogenic Expendible SSTO
      Advanced Rocket Engines
      Air Augmented Rocket Propulsion Concepts
      Improved Saturn V Variants
      History of Soviet Liquid Fueled Engines
      Silbervogel
      The Space Shuttle as an Element in the National Space Program (published 1970)
      Space Shuttle Range Safety Command Destruct System
      Why Does the Space Shuttle Have Wings?: A Look at the Social Construction of Technology in Air and Space
      Human Rated Delta IV
      Ignition! An Informal History of Liquid Rocket Propellants
      Soviet Space Program Handbook (1988)
      Launch Loop
      Atlas V Users Guide
      Current Evaluation of Tripropellant Concept
      Star Raker
      Assessments of Proposed Upgraded (STS, 1999)
      Liquid Flyback Booster Configurations
      Liquid Flyback Booster Study Assessment
      Dual Liquid Flyback Booster for Space Shuttle
      Apollo Lunar Module Propulsion Systems Overview
      Lifting Manned Hypervelocity Reentry Vehicles
      Saturn V Improvement Study
       
      Nuclear Propulsion
       
      Missions to Mars and the Moons of Jupiter and Saturn Utilizing Nuclear Thermal Rockets with Indigenous Propellants
      Nuclear Thermal Rockets Using Indigenous Martian Propellants
      Nuclear Thermal Rocket/VehicIe Design Options for Future NASA Missions to the Moon and Mars
      Nuclear Pulse Propulsion
      Solid Core Nuclear Propulsion Concept
      Development of Nuclear Rocket Engines in the USSR
      NSWR
      Space Nuclear Thermal Propulsion Program
      Rover Nuclear Engine Program Tests
      Design of Antimatter Annihilation Rocket
      Antiproton Powered Propulsion with Magnetically Confined Plasma Engines
      Nuclear Pulse Space Vehicle Study
      SOAR: Space Orbiting Advanced Fusion Power Reactor
      Metal DUMBO Rocket Reactor
      Fission Fragment Rocket Engine
      The Political Feasibility of Nuclear Power in Space
      Liquid Annular Reactor System (LARS)
      On the Use of a Pulsed Nuclear Thermal Rocket for Interstellar Travel
      Fission Fragment Rockets (1988)
       
      Exploration
       
      Lunex
      Soviet Manned Lunar Program
      Solar Rocket System Concept Analysis
      Manned Mars Missions Using Electric Propulsion
      Galactic and Solar Cosmic Ray Shielding
      Issues in Radiation Protection: Galactic Cosmic Rays
      Titan Submersible Proposal
      Discovery of 1992 QB1 (first KBO)
      Color Diversity Among Centaurs and KBOs
      Manned Venus Flyby Proposal (1967)
      Manned Eros Flyby (would have used Apollo derivative possibly)
      Bussard Ramjet (simple)
      Bussard Ramjet (more stuff)
      Comparison of Phobos and Deimos as Exploration Targets
      Scenarios for the Orbits of 2000 CR105 and 2003 VB12
      A couple of spaceflight books
      JIMO Materials Challenges
      Aerocapture Analysis for a Neptune Mission
      Aerogravity Assist at Triton
      Neptune Orbiters Using Solar and Radioisotope Electric Propulsion
      Magnetic Field of Mercury
      Human Exploration of Mercury and Saturn
      Project Mercury Report (1959)
      Abort Options for Mars Missions
      Manned Phobos Mission (Project APEX)
      Manned Venus Orbiting Mission
      High Altitude Venus Operations Concept
      Crewed Mission to Callisto
      Titan and Europa Mission Summary
      Design of a Common Lunar Lander (1991)
      Manned Lunar Habitats
      Meteroid/Debris Shielding
      Interstellar radio links enhanced by exploiting the Sun as a Gravitational Lens.
      Origin and Orbital Distribution of Trans-Neptunian Scattered Disc
      X-Ray Fluorescence from Inner Disc in Cygnus X-1
      Evidence for a Distant Planet in the Outer Solar System
      Evidence for Nemesis (from 1985)
      THE USES OF ASTRONOMY AN ORATION
      Rapid Mars Transits with Exhaust-Modulated Plasma Propulsion
      VASIMIR
      Columbia Crew Survival Investigation Report
      CO2/Metal Propellants for Mars Sample Return Missions
      ISS EVA Radiation Protection Studies
      The Mars Project (Von Braun, 1953)
      That is not dead which can eternal lie: the aestivation hypothesis for resolving Fermi’s paradox
      Nanotechnology and Space System Architecture
      Apollo Guidance Computer Code List
       
       
      Missiles (ICBMs and such, shorter range missiles live in the aviation forum)
       
      Defense Against Ballistic Missiles
      ICBM Basing Options
      Soviet Theater Nuclear Forces: Implications for NATO Defense (1981)
      Seize the High Ground: The Army in Space and Missile Defense
      Soviet Concepts of Ballistic Missile Defense
      ABM R&D at Bell Labs
      Ballistic Missile Defense Report
      A4 User Manual (in German)
      The SS-8 Controversy
       
      Other
       
      Akin's Laws of Spacecraft Design
      A Linear Accelerator in Space
      Astronomical Engineering: A Strategy for Modifying Planetary Orbits
      Boris Chertok Memoir Link to English Translation
      The Problem of Space Travel 1928 by Slovenian Engineer Herman Potočnik
      Rockets and People, by Boris Chertok
       
    • By LostCosmonaut
      There's a shitload of real estate in the solar system, and we don't know much about most of it. What unmanned probes would you like to see built to learn more about the planets and other objects?
       
      My first choice is an Enceladus orbiter/lander; it's one of the best candidates for extraterrestial life, has confirmed cryovolcanism, and organics have been found near it. Plus, any mission you send there can get some bonus science of Titan and other cool places in the Saturn system.
       
      I also like FOCAL, just for the sheer audacity of it.
       
      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FOCAL_(spacecraft)
       
    • By Serge
      I propose a new topic to regroup information about French AFVs.
       
      Days after days, information is overwhelmed under the inflow of photos about anything and everything.
      It can be interesting to try to have dedicated topics to ease the quality of exchanges. 
       
      So, if you have already posted interesting photos, documentations and view about French AFVs, you can quote them here. 
    • By LostCosmonaut
      Metal cooled reactors have several advantages over pressurized water reactors. For one, their power density is greater, additionally, the coolant is unpressurized, improving safety.
       
      However, there are some downsides. The Soviets' Project 705 class submarines were powered by liquid metal reactors utilizing a lead-bismuth alloy as coolant. This alloy had a freezing temperature of roughly 400K. As a result, the reactors had to be run constantly, even while the submarines were in port (there were facilities to provide superheated steam to the reactors while the subs were docked, but they broke down and were never repaired). This reduces the lifetime of the reactor. Another coolant choice which has been used operationally is NaK (Sodium-Potassium). This alloy is liquid at room temperature, but reacts violently with water or air. I'm not an expert, but this seems like a bad thing.
       
       
      It seems to me that if appropriate coolants could be found, it seems that liquid metal fast reactors could see more widespread acceptance. To my untrained eye, gallium looks like a good choice. Its melting point is relatively close to room temperature (~303K), and the boiling point is quite high (over 2600K). Also, gallium is less reactive than sodium or other alkali metals. It appears that there has been some research on this topic: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0149197000000640(unfortunately, the article is behind a paywall), and it looks quite promising.
       
      Anybody have any opinions on this, or suggestions for alternative coolants?
×
×
  • Create New...