Jump to content
Please support this forum by joining the SH Patreon ×
Sturgeon's House

Beer

Contributing Members
  • Posts

    1,394
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    26

Reputation Activity

  1. Funny
    Beer got a reaction from DeXM in Ukrainian armor - Oplot-M, T-64M Bulat and other.   
    It doesn't matter for whom Oryx works or whom he supports. The point is that majority of the documented losses on his blog are real. Most of them have gigantic letters Z and V written on them and a large part of the machinery is also exclusively used only by Russia. There is certainly a grey zone in which certain losses can be attributed to both sides (lostarmour.info for comparison) but that doesn't make the list useless because there is still a lot of undisputable facts which one can take from the database. See, the 4th Guards Kantemirovskaya tank division is the only unit in this war using T-80U family of tanks. Those can't be mixed with Ukrainean. They are Russian and they are of 4th division. That's a fact. This division which was considered one of the best in the Russian army beyond any doubt lost more than 1/3 of its tanks. It doesn't mattter who delivered the message but without Oryx's list we would hardly know that because lostarmour doesn't show Russian losses at all (perhaps is not allowed to do so). 
     
    My previous point that there are most likely numerous Ukrainean losses missing in the database was not about the databse per se. It's natural thing done by the side which controls the territory where losses occur. See how many Azeri losses surfaces only after the 2019 war? We will never know how many never got on public. That's simply the advantage of the side which controls the battlefield and it will continue to be like that in any future conflict.  
  2. Metal
    Beer got a reaction from barbaria in Ukrainian Civil War Thread: All Quiet on the Sturgeon Front   
    This is roughly one complete Russian mechanized battalion destroyed in a failed bridging attempt near Bilohorivka (or Belogorovka in Russian) yesterday. 
     
  3. Tank You
    Beer reacted to LoooSeR in Go Home Robots, You're Drunk!   
  4. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from Voodoo in Ukrainian armor - Oplot-M, T-64M Bulat and other.   
    It doesn't matter for whom Oryx works or whom he supports. The point is that majority of the documented losses on his blog are real. Most of them have gigantic letters Z and V written on them and a large part of the machinery is also exclusively used only by Russia. There is certainly a grey zone in which certain losses can be attributed to both sides (lostarmour.info for comparison) but that doesn't make the list useless because there is still a lot of undisputable facts which one can take from the database. See, the 4th Guards Kantemirovskaya tank division is the only unit in this war using T-80U family of tanks. Those can't be mixed with Ukrainean. They are Russian and they are of 4th division. That's a fact. This division which was considered one of the best in the Russian army beyond any doubt lost more than 1/3 of its tanks. It doesn't mattter who delivered the message but without Oryx's list we would hardly know that because lostarmour doesn't show Russian losses at all (perhaps is not allowed to do so). 
     
    My previous point that there are most likely numerous Ukrainean losses missing in the database was not about the databse per se. It's natural thing done by the side which controls the territory where losses occur. See how many Azeri losses surfaces only after the 2019 war? We will never know how many never got on public. That's simply the advantage of the side which controls the battlefield and it will continue to be like that in any future conflict.  
  5. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from Cleb in Ukrainian armor - Oplot-M, T-64M Bulat and other.   
    It doesn't matter for whom Oryx works or whom he supports. The point is that majority of the documented losses on his blog are real. Most of them have gigantic letters Z and V written on them and a large part of the machinery is also exclusively used only by Russia. There is certainly a grey zone in which certain losses can be attributed to both sides (lostarmour.info for comparison) but that doesn't make the list useless because there is still a lot of undisputable facts which one can take from the database. See, the 4th Guards Kantemirovskaya tank division is the only unit in this war using T-80U family of tanks. Those can't be mixed with Ukrainean. They are Russian and they are of 4th division. That's a fact. This division which was considered one of the best in the Russian army beyond any doubt lost more than 1/3 of its tanks. It doesn't mattter who delivered the message but without Oryx's list we would hardly know that because lostarmour doesn't show Russian losses at all (perhaps is not allowed to do so). 
     
    My previous point that there are most likely numerous Ukrainean losses missing in the database was not about the databse per se. It's natural thing done by the side which controls the territory where losses occur. See how many Azeri losses surfaces only after the 2019 war? We will never know how many never got on public. That's simply the advantage of the side which controls the battlefield and it will continue to be like that in any future conflict.  
  6. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from watch_your_fire in Ukrainian Civil War Thread: All Quiet on the Sturgeon Front   
    That obviously isn't true. 
     
    The island was not deserted which is clearly proven by the fact that there is a lot of secondary explosions from stored ammo and that two more Raptor crafts were hit around the island afterwards. The statement about mechanical failure of a Tor launcher is also good only for someone who didn't see the footage. Overall it was at least two Tors, one Strela 10M and two ZU-23-2 destroyed on the island by the strikes preparing the way for the Su-27 strike. 
     
    Since this part of the statement is obviously untrue I don't see any reason why the rest shall be true.   
     
    Also even the Wagner's RSOFM telegram stated that the destroyed helicopter was Russian and that the island was deserted only afterwards. 
  7. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from Lord_James in Ukrainian armor - Oplot-M, T-64M Bulat and other.   
    It doesn't matter for whom Oryx works or whom he supports. The point is that majority of the documented losses on his blog are real. Most of them have gigantic letters Z and V written on them and a large part of the machinery is also exclusively used only by Russia. There is certainly a grey zone in which certain losses can be attributed to both sides (lostarmour.info for comparison) but that doesn't make the list useless because there is still a lot of undisputable facts which one can take from the database. See, the 4th Guards Kantemirovskaya tank division is the only unit in this war using T-80U family of tanks. Those can't be mixed with Ukrainean. They are Russian and they are of 4th division. That's a fact. This division which was considered one of the best in the Russian army beyond any doubt lost more than 1/3 of its tanks. It doesn't mattter who delivered the message but without Oryx's list we would hardly know that because lostarmour doesn't show Russian losses at all (perhaps is not allowed to do so). 
     
    My previous point that there are most likely numerous Ukrainean losses missing in the database was not about the databse per se. It's natural thing done by the side which controls the territory where losses occur. See how many Azeri losses surfaces only after the 2019 war? We will never know how many never got on public. That's simply the advantage of the side which controls the battlefield and it will continue to be like that in any future conflict.  
  8. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from Zyklon in Ukrainian armor - Oplot-M, T-64M Bulat and other.   
    It doesn't matter for whom Oryx works or whom he supports. The point is that majority of the documented losses on his blog are real. Most of them have gigantic letters Z and V written on them and a large part of the machinery is also exclusively used only by Russia. There is certainly a grey zone in which certain losses can be attributed to both sides (lostarmour.info for comparison) but that doesn't make the list useless because there is still a lot of undisputable facts which one can take from the database. See, the 4th Guards Kantemirovskaya tank division is the only unit in this war using T-80U family of tanks. Those can't be mixed with Ukrainean. They are Russian and they are of 4th division. That's a fact. This division which was considered one of the best in the Russian army beyond any doubt lost more than 1/3 of its tanks. It doesn't mattter who delivered the message but without Oryx's list we would hardly know that because lostarmour doesn't show Russian losses at all (perhaps is not allowed to do so). 
     
    My previous point that there are most likely numerous Ukrainean losses missing in the database was not about the databse per se. It's natural thing done by the side which controls the territory where losses occur. See how many Azeri losses surfaces only after the 2019 war? We will never know how many never got on public. That's simply the advantage of the side which controls the battlefield and it will continue to be like that in any future conflict.  
  9. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from RobertV in UAV thread   
    50 seems to be very inflated number (for whatever reason) but even if it was true it's more than clear that TB-2 is not a suitable weapon for penetrating into well defended airspace. It works better than I thought when used reasonably. 
  10. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from SH_MM in Ukrainian armor - Oplot-M, T-64M Bulat and other.   
    It doesn't matter for whom Oryx works or whom he supports. The point is that majority of the documented losses on his blog are real. Most of them have gigantic letters Z and V written on them and a large part of the machinery is also exclusively used only by Russia. There is certainly a grey zone in which certain losses can be attributed to both sides (lostarmour.info for comparison) but that doesn't make the list useless because there is still a lot of undisputable facts which one can take from the database. See, the 4th Guards Kantemirovskaya tank division is the only unit in this war using T-80U family of tanks. Those can't be mixed with Ukrainean. They are Russian and they are of 4th division. That's a fact. This division which was considered one of the best in the Russian army beyond any doubt lost more than 1/3 of its tanks. It doesn't mattter who delivered the message but without Oryx's list we would hardly know that because lostarmour doesn't show Russian losses at all (perhaps is not allowed to do so). 
     
    My previous point that there are most likely numerous Ukrainean losses missing in the database was not about the databse per se. It's natural thing done by the side which controls the territory where losses occur. See how many Azeri losses surfaces only after the 2019 war? We will never know how many never got on public. That's simply the advantage of the side which controls the battlefield and it will continue to be like that in any future conflict.  
  11. Tank You
    Beer reacted to LoooSeR in Ukrainian Civil War Thread: All Quiet on the Sturgeon Front   
    “Unfortunately, we are forced to state that the video of the destruction of the Mi-8AMTSh from Zmeiny Island is not the result of the work of the RF Armed Forces. This is a Russian helicopter destroyed by the Armed Forces of Ukraine.
     
    The board was assigned to the 487th separate helicopter regiment. The deputy commander of the regiment for military-political work was also killed. Eternal memory to the fallen.
     
    The island is now in a gray area."
     
    They are even worse than i thought before.
  12. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from Żółć in Ukrainian Civil War Thread: All Quiet on the Sturgeon Front   
    That obviously isn't true. 
     
    The island was not deserted which is clearly proven by the fact that there is a lot of secondary explosions from stored ammo and that two more Raptor crafts were hit around the island afterwards. The statement about mechanical failure of a Tor launcher is also good only for someone who didn't see the footage. Overall it was at least two Tors, one Strela 10M and two ZU-23-2 destroyed on the island by the strikes preparing the way for the Su-27 strike. 
     
    Since this part of the statement is obviously untrue I don't see any reason why the rest shall be true.   
     
    Also even the Wagner's RSOFM telegram stated that the destroyed helicopter was Russian and that the island was deserted only afterwards. 
  13. Tank You
    Beer reacted to Glattrohr in Ukrainian armor - Oplot-M, T-64M Bulat and other.   
    Appears that there's still some T-84 Oplots in the fight.
     
    Posted 2.5.2022, location unknown : https://vm.tiktok.com/ZMLWXRg1J/
  14. Tank You
    Beer reacted to Żółć in United States Military Vehicle General: Guns, G*vins, and Gas Turbines   
    I wouldn't call it a plan. There are talks that the polish defence sector is cooperating with US manufacturers to create such a facility in Poland, but there is no hard proof. At this time, there are no signed arrangements, so nobody knows who will be providing maintenance and repair for our Abrams tanks. In the best-case scenario, the facility should be part of the Polish Armaments Group presumably located in Bumar (former T-family tanks factory) or WZM (Leopard maintenance facility), in the worst-case scenario, there will be no such facility in Poland or (slightly better scenario) it will be a facility owned by GDLS. So basically, the future holds the answer. 
  15. Sad
    Beer got a reaction from Laviduce in The Soviet Tank Thread: Transversely Mounted 1000hp Engines   
    New view of the destroyed T-90M near Kharkiv.
     
  16. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from Lord_James in United States Military Vehicle General: Guns, G*vins, and Gas Turbines   
    Żółć may correct me but I believe there is a plan for having joint US/Polish repair and mainteanance facility for M1 in Poland adjacent to the new US forward storage base. I don't know how much of a real advantage it is to have Germany as a supplier of the Leos just over the border. The German foreign and military policy has been fickle and the tanks are produced in Greece anyway. 
     
    I agree with the weight. Same issue for our eventual purchase. 
  17. Tank You
    Beer reacted to Alzoc in The Soviet Tank Thread: Transversely Mounted 1000hp Engines   
    1996 video showing the famous Russian log in use (most likely at training):
     
    First time I saw a video with the complete procedure shown actually.
  18. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from Alzoc in United States Military Vehicle General: Guns, G*vins, and Gas Turbines   
    Żółć may correct me but I believe there is a plan for having joint US/Polish repair and mainteanance facility for M1 in Poland adjacent to the new US forward storage base. I don't know how much of a real advantage it is to have Germany as a supplier of the Leos just over the border. The German foreign and military policy has been fickle and the tanks are produced in Greece anyway. 
     
    I agree with the weight. Same issue for our eventual purchase. 
  19. Tank You
    Beer reacted to Alzoc in French flair   
    First fours Serval (VBMR light) delivered to the army :
     

     
    https://www.forcesoperations.com/le-ministere-des-armees-receptionne-les-quatre-premiers-serval/
  20. Tank You
    Beer reacted to Wiedzmin in Israeli AFVs   
    Mk3 turrets, left with cast parts, right welded from plates
     

     
    mk 1-2 
  21. Tank You
    Beer reacted to VPZ in Israeli AFVs   
  22. Tank You
    Beer reacted to Volke in United States Military Vehicle General: Guns, G*vins, and Gas Turbines   
    K2 hasn't failed any bid in Poland yet, we bought Abrams outside the Wilk MBT programme as a replacement for rapidly aging T-72M and M1s. The main future MBT project is still ongoing, and K2PL is the favourite so far. Thing is, it doesn't exist, and who knows how long it will take to build it, and even then who knows if politicians won't change their minds.
  23. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from Clan_Ghost_Bear in United States Military Vehicle General: Guns, G*vins, and Gas Turbines   
    Even though it's not in Eastern Europe Czechia is likely one of those opportunities. Though the expected number of new MBTs is very low (two battalions at best). 
  24. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from LoooSeR in Very informative interviews with Czech pilots   
    Hi guys, 
    long time, no see. Here I have something of a really high informative value. Very long (2-3 hours) and detailed interviews with former pilots of our combat planes with English subtitles (at the moment some final parts remain to be translated). If you are interested in stuff like training and tactical procedures, pilot's life, various peculiar details, technical details, radio, navigation and weapon equipment, accidents or their experience with foreign machines just watch. 
     
    Col. Václav Vašek
    - pilot of L-29, L-39, MiG-21, MiG-23, MiG-29, B-737, A320 
    - display and test pilot of MiG-29
     
     
    Lt. Col. Josef Miler 
    - pilot of L-29, L-39, MiG-21, MiG-23
    - display and test pilot of MiG-23
     
     
    Col. Leoš Liška
    - pilot of L-29, L-39, Su-25
    - display pilot of Su-25
     
     
    According to the author more will come in the future. 
  25. Tank You
    Beer got a reaction from Clan_Ghost_Bear in Very informative interviews with Czech pilots   
    Hi guys, 
    long time, no see. Here I have something of a really high informative value. Very long (2-3 hours) and detailed interviews with former pilots of our combat planes with English subtitles (at the moment some final parts remain to be translated). If you are interested in stuff like training and tactical procedures, pilot's life, various peculiar details, technical details, radio, navigation and weapon equipment, accidents or their experience with foreign machines just watch. 
     
    Col. Václav Vašek
    - pilot of L-29, L-39, MiG-21, MiG-23, MiG-29, B-737, A320 
    - display and test pilot of MiG-29
     
     
    Lt. Col. Josef Miler 
    - pilot of L-29, L-39, MiG-21, MiG-23
    - display and test pilot of MiG-23
     
     
    Col. Leoš Liška
    - pilot of L-29, L-39, Su-25
    - display pilot of Su-25
     
     
    According to the author more will come in the future. 
×
×
  • Create New...