Jump to content
Please support this forum by joining the SH Patreon ×
Sturgeon's House

TINDALOS

Contributing Members
  • Posts

    90
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Posts posted by TINDALOS

  1. As we can see in the Ukrainian side of videos and photos, the registration of that first downed Su-34 is RF-95070. And from a simple search, I confirmed that RF-95070 is a Su-34 numbered "Red 06". HOWEVER, the paint job of that registration number seems wierd to me, in reality the registration number painted on tail never allianed with the "России" paint. Also Red 06's tail tip is grey, not white.

    B1bMlyk.jpgjFHGhGu.jpgFNP85TlXsAQF1Ab.jpg190359.jpg

     

    For the second downed Su-34, no registration number were shown but from the patch we can confirm that it is a Su-34 from the 2nd Guards Bomber Aviation Regiment stationed in Chelyabinsk Oblast. The plane is numbered as "Red 24" (the only aircraft in this regiment that has a patch painted on side while having green+light blue camoflage I think). HOWEVER, if we look closer we will find out that the camo pattern does not match with existing photo evidences. The patch should be on the border of two different colors of the camoflage but in the wreck footage it is not. And that patch also seems too small to me... The 

    Tweets with replies by Mike Yeo 杨启铭 (@TheBaseLeg) / TwitterLjvVJUi.jpg

     

    In conclusion both "downed" Russian Su-34s might be Ukrainian propaganda.

     

     

  2. On 3/5/2022 at 11:12 AM, Domus Acipenseris said:

    The missile used here is said to be a Polish Piorun, a missile designed to engage low flying targets.

     

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-SSEjdmglFc

     

    Apparently a Su-34 was shot down by an Osa missile as well.

     

    I thought the Russians would begin an air campaign after their missile strikes attrited Ukraine's GBAD.  However, we see Su-34's down in the engagement envelope of Osa.  Why?  I suppose they are trying to deliver unguided munitions from an altitude where there is some accuracy.  Perhaps they have to dip below the clouds to deliver guided munitions.  Either way it's farcical to see planes in that envelope in the year 2022.  Especially a rare and expensive Su-34.

     

    Analyst Justin Bronk writes about the Russian Air Force here:  https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/rusi-defence-systems/russian-air-force-actually-incapable-complex-air-operations

    Then I suggest this author to review NATO's air operation in Kosovo... This whole article is based on the assumption that Ukraine has a "weak" air defence network while in fact it might be the best in Europe (exclude Russia). Seven to eight regiments of S-300PS, aound 70+ BUK-M1, 150+ Strella-10M, 100+ OSA-AKM, and about a thousand MANPADS are no joke. Its armed force is much more better equipped than Iraq and Serbia, plus it might be recieving NATO intel collected from NATO's AWACS assets loitering in Poland every single day.

  3. On 3/5/2022 at 11:12 AM, Domus Acipenseris said:

    The missile used here is said to be a Polish Piorun, a missile designed to engage low flying targets.

     

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-SSEjdmglFc

     

    Apparently a Su-34 was shot down by an Osa missile as well.

     

    I thought the Russians would begin an air campaign after their missile strikes attrited Ukraine's GBAD.  However, we see Su-34's down in the engagement envelope of Osa.  Why?  I suppose they are trying to deliver unguided munitions from an altitude where there is some accuracy.  Perhaps they have to dip below the clouds to deliver guided munitions.  Either way it's farcical to see planes in that envelope in the year 2022.  Especially a rare and expensive Su-34.

     

    Analyst Justin Bronk writes about the Russian Air Force here:  https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/rusi-defence-systems/russian-air-force-actually-incapable-complex-air-operations

    I think the reason might be that they are trying to dodge BUK-M1 and S-300's engagement envelop. In 1999 NATO forces launched nearly 400 HARMs against Serbian KUBs and only got to destroy three out of twenty two batteries. And we know that the survivalbility of BUKs are much higher than KUBs...

  4. 36 minutes ago, Volke said:

    Yeah im pretty sure it was attacked by NLAW, as on picture we can see that the projectile came from the side, not from top, as for Javelins, indeed they didn't seem to appear yet. Quite interesting why we see no footage of em.

    I also suspect the missing turret era and side fuel tank fire were from different attack attempts by RPG-7 or Konkurs ATGM. Can we identify wether this T-72 is B3 variant or simply 1989 variant? Another 1989 variant I saw today was not as lucky as this one.

  5. 1 hour ago, Volke said:

    Zdjęcie
    Seems the cages aren't that useless in the end, it detonated the top attack missile before it could reach the crew compartment and so only the fuel tank next to turret got ignited.

    I think these cages are actually useful against NLAWs due to NLAWs fly pattern (look closer you will find out those turret top ERAs didn't suffer much of a damage, I could be wrong), but maybe kind of useless against Javleins? Besides, I didn't see a single Javelin launch video or UKR troop carrying Javelins over the internet yet... I wonder did they ever managed to use those?

  6. 12 minutes ago, Pardus said:

     

    Suuuure....

     

    swuyre26vyj81.jpg?width=640&crop=smart&a

    q32wq683szj81.jpg?width=640&crop=smart&a

     

     

    img_76-7_1.jpg?itok=ptuxM6li

     

    So very anti communist...

    If you are so well knowledged on "Russian Propaganda", you should definitely know that Putin only brings out USSR's historical legacy when it fits in his narrative (such as bring the nationalism aspect of great patriotic war up while supress the anti-fascist and communist ideological aspect), other times he bash USSR HARD. Even Viktor Orban gave out a couple good words to communist (not really) Hungary by saying communist Hungary is a welfare state, did this make he a communist too?

  7. 6 minutes ago, Pardus said:

     

    Suuuure....

     

    swuyre26vyj81.jpg?width=640&crop=smart&a

    q32wq683szj81.jpg?width=640&crop=smart&a

     

     

    img_76-7_1.jpg?itok=ptuxM6li

     

    So very anti communist...

    Lmao, that did not stop Putin trash talk about Lenin and accuse Lenin for the creation of a Ukraine nation in his speech a couple days ago, also it did not stop Putin's long history of parising white guards while condemn communism as "evil abd degenerate". You really think a couple of red cloth with hammer and sickle on it mean THAT much?

  8. 1 hour ago, Toxn said:

    Agreed. I'm getting real "Baghdad Bob but now we're all Iraqis" vibes from all of this.

    Since no one is getting hurt in the "civilized world" besides mental trauma, If the general public find peace through these reports than I would respect their choice. As for the blood shed thousand kilometers away from them, who cares lol? Everthing will be forgotten after one or two months when life is back into track (or it never leaves the track?), especially for those who does not even know where Ukraine is on the world map. As for those who actively "support" the Ukraine war effort through patreon or merchandise (like that Warthunder youtuber freak), they earn big bucks even if Ukraine military got completely smashed by Russians. So I guess it is truly a win win situation :)

  9. 16 minutes ago, Pardus said:

     

    No'one is claiming the western world and its governments are all perfect. But the people who are trying convince others that they're no better than the criminal states & dictatorships in the east, middle east and asia, they're simply not in touch with reality - not to mention utterly oblivious to the privileges they enjoy if they themselves live in the west. 

     

    There's simply no excuse for invading a democratic country where people are living a free life, which was very much not the case in Iraq, Syria or Afghanistan. That the US pulled out of Afghanistan like they did, I was also disgusted by, now the women there are once again living an imprisoned life with no rights.

    I hope you does not believe in there are any thing very liberal about the world economic order established post Yalta. You can't support some thing that never existed right? It's all about profit and gains at the end of the day.... And that's the exact reason why a SBCT or a NATO rapid response task force is not battaling with Russians on the outskirt of Kiev after three days of Russian warmachine steam rolling Ukraine's pathetic military.

  10. 4 minutes ago, Pardus said:

     

    No'one is claiming the western world and its governments are all perfect. But the people who are trying convince others that they're no better than the criminal states & dictatorships in the east, middle east and asia, they're simply not in touch with reality - not to mention utterly oblivious to the privileges they enjoy if they themselves live in the west. 

     

    There's simply no excuse for invading a democratic country where people are living a free life, which was very much not the case in Iraq, Syria or Afghanistan. That the US pulled out of Afghanistan like they did, I was also disgusted by, now the women there are once again living an imprisoned life with no rights.

    Sorry, empire got what they want. This unfortunately applies to all major powers on Earth. France got what it want in Africa, US got what it want in middle east, China got what it want in Southeast Asia and Africa, Russia got what it want in Ukraine. Oh, and if think deliever weapons can actually help you are absolutely wrong. I wonder when will thoes weapon show up in the Central Armed Force museum? Gotta plan another trip to Russland next year :P

  11. 9 minutes ago, Pardus said:

     

    NATO imperialist expansion?? Sure, if you consider trying to spread democracy, freedom of press & speech, and protect people from criminal states imperialistic.

     

    I think you're forgetting NATO is a defense pact, created precisely in response to piranha states like the one Putin is ruling with an iron fist. 

     

    Hence little Putin's reckless actions are only incentivizing MORE states to join NATO, such as Sweden & Finland = The exact thing the little maniac claims he wants to avoid, and has already threatened nuclear war over.

    dEFeNSiVe pAcT

    Does not matter, since after the collapse of soviet block they were already within the strong sphere of influence of NATO for 30 years or so. A nice parable would be: cover your head with a hood does not change your skin color.

×
×
  • Create New...