Jump to content
Please support this forum by joining the SH Patreon ×
Sturgeon's House

Vanagandr

Forum Nobility
  • Posts

    1,051
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Reputation Activity

  1. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to Donward in B-21 Bomber Unveiled   
    It needs to be armed with .50 cal defensive armament since a .50 cal bullet will tear a MiG's wing off even if it misses.
  2. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to xthetenth in The Weird and Wonderful World of North Carolina Designs (also general ship design stuff)   
    So I got goaded into writing posts about the North Carolina class.
     
    For additional reading about warship design:

    http://navweaps.com/index_tech/tech-035.htm (I moved this up to the front because it's good and I'm angling for a general thing here).
     
    The weird and wonderful world of North Carolina sketches

    So the US found itself in the mid 1930s with a need for a new battleship with a treaty in place limiting it to 35k tons displacement and 14 inch guns. The first and most important thing about this design process is that they were in the middle of figuring out what a modern navy was and how it should work. They'd traditionally prioritized protection at the expense of speed and slightly less so firepower, giving them a battle line of slow football shaped things that could take a pounding and dish one out.

    Problem was those damnable carrier things. The first US carrier, the Langley, was a slow collier conversion, but the next two were conversions of the battlecruisers Lexington and Saratoga, (which were a lot like the mad, flammable fever dreams of Jackie Fisher in terms of protection, so it was probably a good thing in the end). The reason for this was the negotiations for the treaty. Unlike in RtW there was a lot of quid pro quo. The US had just finished the Colorado, Maryland and West Virginia, and the Japanese had just finished the Nagato and Mutsu. The British had the Courageous, Glorious, and Furious, which were in severe danger of starting to make sense. So the UK got to build the Nelsons so they could have nice modern battleships armed with and against 16" guns, and the US and Japan could get some carriers.

    So the US built the Lexingtons, which promptly showed the supremacy of the big fast carrier. Not only could they get places really quick to do important carrier things, they could also operate planes in larger numbers much more easily and in much worse weather. So the treaty carrier force was decided on being hulls as big as they could make them and 30+ knots. Suddenly that 21 knot battleship speed looks like a massive operational and strategic liability if they want to not have their carriers run in fright at sight of a battleship (This is still the time of the Lexington class carrying a heavy 8" armament to fight off cruisers, air power just couldn't be expected to head off heavy surface attack and conceding the sea wasn't necessarily a winner).

    The sum of all this was that they knew they were going to be making a major departure to what had gone before but they really weren't sure what that would be. To this end they tried a lot of ideas to see what they could get. These ideas are A, A1, B, B1, C, C1, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, J1, K, L, 1, 3, 4, I, II, II-A, III, IV, IV-A, IV-B, IX-C, IX-D, IX-E, X-A, X-B, XI-A, XI-B, IV-C, V, VI-A, VI-B, VII, VIII, IX-A, IX-B, XII, XIII, XIII-A, XIII-B, XIV, XV, XV-A, XV-B, XV-C, XV-E, XVI, XVI-A, XVI-B, XVI-C, XVI-D (Word says that list has 55 commas so that's 56 sets of specs considered).

    For obvious reasons I'm going to talk more about the fun designs.

    Scheme A had 3 triple 14" turrets forward and 30 knots speed with a thin 11.5" belt. A1 added to the belt with 13.5" and the same 9x14".

    B and C tried for more protection and a more conventional layout. BuOrd introduced a super-heavy 14" shell that made their targets for immune zone unattainable, (that's where A1 comes from).

    The CNO asked for ideas for a minimum displacement ship emphasizing defensive features. They didn't get dignified with an actual name on that list (Preliminary design called the worst, with 8x12" and 23 knots a deathtrap).

    D and E were armed with the shiny new 16" rifle to see what a ship armed with and armored against it would look like. However after a thorough search of their couch cushions, they couldn't turn up the 5,000 tons to make them fit the treaty limits.

    F makes me cry. 8 guns in two rear mounted quads. Wait, rear? They needed to free up the front for the three aircraft catapults. FDR apparently liked this demented battleship version of what the Tone class did better.

    G and H were slow 23 knot designs. They were nice, reasonable, balanced battleships and the spiritual successors of the standards. They also didn't fit the fleet's needs.

    So that left them looking at a 30 knot ship or a slower, better armed ship. Yes, this is the USN that previously considered a battleship to be a football made of armor.

    J tried to go with four turrets. It turns out that getting an idea and hammering the belt armor down to 8" to make it work is frowned upon.

    K made the belt narrower over A1 to make it thicker, but was considered too tight to the treaty limit.

    L is where we get to the good stuff and bring back the noble quadruple turret, which would have been 12 guns forward and crazy fun to play in WoWS.

    After that we get the thirty five (that we know of) sketch designs elaborating on those ideas. I through V show the development of the brilliant feature of fitting the ship for but not with 100 rounds more than the 100 per gun to save weight by careful manipulation of paper. I and II moved a turret aft to see if they could save weight there.

    Anyway, this is dragging on, I'll just post this and add a part 2 so we can get further adventures of people trying desperately trying to fit 40k+ tons of battleship that people can't even decide on the shape of into 35k tons.
     
  3. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from Sturgeon in General PC games master race thread. Everything about games. EVERYTHING.   
    Speaking of hackers, found one on KF2 today, he instantly shot to top of killboard when he joined last while playing a class that focuses on killing smaller numbers of big things, he was killing things with one shot that he shouldn't have been able to, things would die near him without being shot at, etc. Called him on it, and he plays dumb and says "who's hacking?". We point out how blatant his hacking is, that he has game bans on record on his steam profile, and his steam profile advertises CSGO boosting services, then he starts saying "yeah, I'm hacking, here's a link to the hacks I'm using, everyone wants to hack" (the rest of that is paraphrase, but he literally said "everyone wants to hack"). We tell him to fuck off and ask him why he even bothers playing, he says he is grinding XP, I ask why he would bother when he could just hack his XP to max level, and here is the punchline to end all punchlines; he says "that's illegal"
  4. Tank You
  5. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to Toxn in Black powder thread   
    To start:
     
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mwhmk-4bDS4
     
    Yeah... there's going to be a lot of capandball posts, methinks.
  6. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from LoooSeR in The Enema Thread (Moderator: Tied)   
    Remember when animea wasn't bad for your health?
  7. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to Alex C. in General cars and vehicles thread.   
    I always run leaded stuff in older engines for valve lubrication/preventing valve seat wear. He also mentioned it running hotter than hell, so the 100LL likely prevents detonation (as he said he can only run it for 15 minutes before it overheats).
  8. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from Sturgeon in Aerospace Pictures and Art Thread   
    This reminds me, I got to piss around with landing gear from a B-2 the other day
    In case I ever need to change out wheels or brakes on a B-2, I am now theoretically capable (although not technically qualified)
     
    I'll put up some pictures of the craft in the hangar some time
  9. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to dakata552 in BlackTailDefense Doesn't Know Shit About Tank Design   
    I made an account only to comment and support that BRD is absolute retard. He is also a FURRY which is all you need to know to understand that he is absolute retard. ABSOLUTE FURRY RETARD. HOW THE FUCK ARE YOU GOING TO COMPARE SHERMAN WITH AN ABRAMS?
  10. Tank You
  11. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to Donward in Bears can be total assholes. And other bear related news   
    Misleading Online Profile Leads To Date With BAAAEEEYYYEEERRR.
     
    https://www.bearmageddonnews.com/2016/09/02/misleading-online-dating-profile-leads-to-date-with-bear/
     
    (Hattip Bearmageddon News Network)
  12. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to CrashbotUS in Lets talk about languages   
  13. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from Collimatrix in Coolant Choices for Liquid-Metal Fast Reactors   
    So, I played music at the Iowa State Fair recently, the guy who I carpooled with is an electrician of some sort at the local nuclear power plant. Something interesting I learned from him is that reactors that use sodium for heat exchange actually use induction to cycle the sodium (or at least the one he used to work at did).
  14. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to Sturgeon in The terrible movies and reviews thread   
    What the fuck


  15. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from Sturgeon in The Small Arms Thread, Part 8: 2018; ICSR to be replaced by US Army with interim 15mm Revolver Cannon.   
    What's worse is that I've been dumb enough to have that happen to me twice
  16. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to Walter_Sobchak in The M4 Sherman Tank Epic Information Thread.. (work in progress)   
    No, as far as I know 75mm shells were literally 75 mm.  This is because they are based on the old French 75mm field gun.  US 76mm shells are based on the US 3 inch gun, so technically they are 76.2mm. The US 3 inch gun and the US 76mm guns used different ammo, despite having the same bore.  Perhaps that is what people are thinking of.
     
    The other confusing bit of tank gun nomenclature is the British 17 pounder and 77mm gun.  The British 17 pounder was also a 76.2mm (three inch) gun.  The Comet also had a 76.2mm gun, but since it took different ammo than the 17pounder, the British called it a 77mm gun to avoid confusion.  
  17. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from Zyklon in Syrian conflict.   
    NSFW, actually fairly disturbing, URL spells it out pretty well
  18. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to Sturgeon in The terrible movies and reviews thread   
  19. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from EnsignExpendable in BlackTailDefense Doesn't Know Shit About Tank Design   
    A7V had 18 crew
    Germany stronkest
  20. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from Jeeps_Guns_Tanks in BlackTailDefense Doesn't Know Shit About Tank Design   
    A7V had 18 crew
    Germany stronkest
  21. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from LoooSeR in WoT v WT effort-thread   
    This isn't our ApplesauceBandit is it?
  22. Tank You
    Vanagandr reacted to Oedipus Wreckx-n-Effect in Get Away, Damnit. (The Camping Thread)   
    This is a thread about camping. Camping is the act of purposely leaving the house and wifi connection in order to sleep on the ground, sometimes in the cold. You may choose to consume less than appetizing food and be at the mercy of nature during this time.
     
    This thread can be used for discussion of items one would take during such a time.
     
    I did such an event with my girlfriend this weekend. I drove up some rather ungroomed roads to Crystal Mountain, west of Fort Collins.  Here is the proof.
     

     

     
     

     

  23. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from Sturgeon in BlackTailDefense Doesn't Know Shit About Tank Design   
    A7V had 18 crew
    Germany stronkest
  24. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from Walter_Sobchak in BlackTailDefense Doesn't Know Shit About Tank Design   
    A7V had 18 crew
    Germany stronkest
  25. Tank You
    Vanagandr got a reaction from Sturgeon in Collimatrix's Terrible Music Thread   
    Oh shit I didn't realize I was being derogatory towards National Socialists and their message of friendship, peace, and tolerance
    Somewhere there's an image of someone talking about how Nazism is really misunderstood and we're just gonna have to pretend I linked it because I don't want to google "nazism ideology of peace"
×
×
  • Create New...